Description: Highlights • Sea-ice cover limits the accumulation of both coccoliths and alkenones in sediments. • Calcite dissolution in shelf sediments may explain the accumulation of alkenones in the presence of few or no coccoliths. • Non-calcifying haptophytes most likely produce alkenones in nearshore environments. Abstract We determined the abundances and concentrations of coccoliths and alkenones in 66 surface sediment samples from the northwest North Atlantic to evaluate the role that surface ocean temperature, salinity, sea-ice cover, and productivity have on the regional distribution of these two biological remains produced by haptophytes in the photic zone. In areas with sea-ice cover of more than 1 month per year, coccolith and alkenone concentrations in sediments are extremely low to nil. Elsewhere, the distribution of coccolith taxa generally displays strong relationships to water temperature, salinity, and productivity. Coccolithus pelagicus is associated with low summer sea-surface temperatures (〈8°C) and relatively high summer sea-surface salinities (〉33.5), whereas Helicosphaera carteri seems to follow the path of the North Atlantic Drift. The distribution of Emiliania huxleyi, the dominant alkenone producer, is not strongly correlated with that of alkenones. Calcite dissolution in shelf sediments could explain the occurrence of alkenones in the absence of coccoliths but alkenone production by non-calcifying haptophytes seems to also exert some control on alkenone concentrations in surface sediments, thus blurring alkenone abundance links to coccolithophorid production and their relative preservation.