Description: In the course of converting the energy supply from fossil-based to more sustainable regenerative energy resources, the use of the geological underground for energy storage purposes is becoming increasingly important to achieve the national climate policy goals. The geological underground offers opportunities for the storage of hydrogen, CO2 and synthetic gas as well as for the permanent storage of hazardous and environmentally harmful substances, e.g. radioactive waste. In the course of the energy transition and the discussion on climate change mitigation options, the demand for new storage technologies and corresponding scientific research is increasing. An indispensable prerequisite for the further development of new storage technologies are scientific pilot sites and underground research laboratories. Building on its expertise in geological storage, the GFZ is conducting projects for CO2 and H2 storage as well as for nuclear waste disposal to study technological implementation and long-term safety. This research forms an indispensible contribution of the region Germany/Central Europe to the European climate and energy strategy.

Description: Marine controlled source electromagnetic (CSEM) data have been analyzed as part of a larger interdisciplinary field study to reveal the distribution and concentration of gas hydrates and free gas in two working areas (WAs) in the offshore Danube fan in the western Black Sea. The areas are located in the Bulgarian sector in about 1500 m water depth (WA1) and in the Romanian sector in about 650 m water depth (WA2). Both areas are characterized by channel levee systems and wide spread occurrences of multiple bottom simulating reflections (BSRs) suggesting the presence of gas hydrates. Electrical resistivity models have been derived from two-dimensional (2D) inversions of inline CSEM data using a seafloor-towed electric dipole-dipole system. Comparing the resistivity models with coincident reflection seismic profiles reveals insight in the sediment stratigraphy of the gas hydrate stability zone (GHSZ). Gas hydrate and free gas saturation estimates have been derived with a stochastic approach of Archie's relationship considering uncertainties in the input parameters available from drilling with the MeBo-200 seafloor rig in WA2. The resistivity models generally reflect the transition of marine to lacustrine conditions expressed by a sharp decay of pore water salinities in the top 30–40 m below seafloor caused by freshwater phases of the Black Sea due to sea level low stands in the past. In WA1, we derived saturation estimates of 10–20% within a 100 m thick layer at around 50 m depth below the channel which compares well with estimates from seismic P-wave velocities. The layer extends below the western levee with even higher saturations of 20–30%, but high gas hydrate saturations are unlikely within the fine grained, clayey sediment section, and the high resistivities may reflect different lithologies of lower permeability and porosity. The resistive layer terminates below the eastern levee where increasing resistivities at depth towards a stack of multiple BSRs indicate gas hydrate and free gas concentrations in the order of 10% to locally 30%. WA2 is characterized by a major slope failure at the landward edge of the gas hydrate stability field next to the channel. Gas hydrate saturation estimates within the slump area are close to zero within the GHSZ which is in agreement with coring results of the nearby MeBo drill sites. Elevated resistivities below the steeply upward bending BSR lead to saturation estimates less than 10% of free gas that may have accumulated.

Description: Between 2008 and 2013, the German Research Centre for Geosciences – GFZ has injected more than 67 kt of CO2 at the Pilot Site in Ketzin, 25 km west of Berlin. The CO2 was stored in porous sandstones of the Upper Triassic Stuttgart Formation at a depth of 630 to 650 m. In more than a decade, GFZ has developed and tested an extraordinary multi-monitoring concept for onshore CO2 storages which mainly comprises the following methods: Time-lapse 3D seismic surveying is the most commonly used method for imaging and monitoring a CO2-plume in the deep underground before, during and after the injection phase. Such campaigns require high logistical and financial efforts and can be realised only to a limited extent. At Ketzin, for instance, 3D-seismic repeat surveys were acquired using several thousand surface acquisition points and lasting over two or three months. Alternative approaches include permanently buried seismic receivers. Geoelectric measurements in Ketzin are mainly applied by using a permanent downhole electrode installation (Vertical Electrical Resistivity Array = VERA) which has been implemented in three wells behind the well casings. Measurements between 590 m to 735 m are constantly carried out covering the vertical thickness of the entire CO2 storage horizon. Valuable results were achieved by a combination of inhole, crosshole and surface downhole measurements which has been carried out with appropriate acquisition geometries. For focused areas around monitoring wells, geoelectric methods may support and supplement information from seismic surveys. Borehole monitoring of pressure and temperature are generally indispensable for every underground gas storage type. In Ketzin, a remote monitoring system for all wells has been installed that constantly provides the operators with values for date, time, downhole and wellhead pressure, depth, and temperature. Moreover, all wellheads are checked weekly during onsite inspections. Samples for chemical analysis are taken in regular intervals from an observation well. With a total depth of 418 m, the well reaches the natural brine filled sandstones of the Triassic Exter Formation which represents the layer straight upon the caprock of the CO2 reservoir. Fluid samples are being analysed for stable carbon isotopes 13C, dissolved organic carbon (DIC) and pH. Any significant intrusion of CO2 into this aquifer would cause distinct anomalies and trigger alarm conditions. Another regularly applied monitoring method in Ketzin is the measurement of soil CO2 flux. Natural CO2 flux is generated by the respiration of roots and soil organisms and the decomposition of organic matter. Both processes very much depend on the seasons respectively on the soil temperature. Outliers of the natural background range could indicate a leakage in the reservoir.

Description: At the Ketzin pilot site, a permanent downhole electrode array has been utilized as part of the multi-disciplinary monitoring concept during all phases of the CO2 storage project. After more than seven years under the present CO2/brine prevailing subsurface conditions, including the five years of regular CO2 injection, a first long-term evaluation of the general technical performance of the electrode array can be given. This article reports on the application of the crosshole electrical resistivity tomography (ERT) technique considering the site specific requirements and challenges. It describes the installation procedure of the electrode array, field data acquisition schemes and automated pre-processing routines applied to the continuously growing data archive. It has been found that the evaluation of contact resistance measurements provides useful information about the current condition of the downhole installation. The 3D time-lapse inversion of one of the major observation planes yields resistivity distributions from various operational stages during the injection and post-injection phases of the CO2 storage reservoir. A simple saturation approach converts averaged resistivity signatures from the target reservoir zone into CO2 saturation estimates, which are in good agreement with saturation results measured by borehole logging campaigns. The permanent ERT array has shown a promising lifespan under downhole conditions, and is able to provide complementary information in conjunction with other monitoring systems. For further practical applications, a more standardized workflow for data acquisition and processing might be beneficial.

Description: The Ketzin pilot site in Germany is the longest operating on-shore CO2 storage site in Europe. From June 2008 till August 2013, a total of 67,000 tonnes of CO2 were safely stored in a saline aquifer at depths of 630 m to 650 m. The storage site has now entered the abandonment phase, and continuation of the multi-disciplinary monitoring as part of the national project "CO2 post-injection monitoring and post-closure phase at the Ketzin pilot site "(COMPLETE) provides the unique chance to participate in the conclusion of the complete life cycle of a CO2 storage site. As part of the continuous evaluation of the functionality and integrity of the CO2 storage in Ketzin, from Octo- ber 12, 2015 till January 6, 2015 a total of 2,900 tonnes of brine were successfully injected into the CO2 reservoir, hereby simulating in time-lapse the natural backflow of brine and the associated displacement of CO2. The main objectives of this brine injection experiment include investigation of how much of the CO2 in the pore space can be displaced by brine and if this displacement of CO2 during the brine injection differs from the displacement of formation fluid during the initial CO2 injection. Geophysical monitoring of the brine injection included continuous geoelectric measurements accompanied by monitoring of pressure and temperature conditions in the injection well and two adjacent observation wells. During the previous CO2 injection, the geoelectrical monitoring concept at the Ketzin pilot site consisted of permanent crosshole measurements and non-permanent large-scale surveys (Kiessling et al., 2010). Time-lapse geoelectrical tomographies derived from the weekly crosshole data at near-wellbore scale complemented by six surface- downhole surveys at a scale of 1.5 km showed a noticeable resistivity signature within the target storage zone, which was attributed to the CO2 plume (Schmidt-Hattenberger et al., 2011) and interpreted in terms of relative CO2 and brine saturations (Bergmann et al., 2012). During the brine injection, usage of a new data acquisition unit allowed the daily collection of an extended crosshole data set. This data set was complemented by an alternative surface-downhole acquisition geometry, which for the first time allowed for regular current injections from three permanent surface electrodes into the existing electrical resistivity downhole array without the demand of an extensive field survey. This alternative surface-downhole acquisition geometry is expected to be characterized by good data quality and well confined sensitivity to the target storage zone. Time-lapse geoelectrical tomographies have been derived from both surface-downhole and crosshole data and show a conductive signature around the injection well associated with the displacement of CO2 by the injected brine. In addition to the above mentioned objectives of this brine injection experiment, comparative analysis of the surface-downhole and crosshole data provides the opportunity to evaluate the alternative surface-downhole acquisition geometry with respect to its resolution within the target storage zone and its ability to quantitatively constrain the displacement of CO2 during the brine injection. These results will allow for further improvement of the deployed alternative surface-downhole acquisition geometries.

Description: Marine controlled source electromagnetic (CSEM) data have been collected to investigate methane seep sites and associated gas hydrate deposits at Opouawe Bank on the southern tip of the Hikurangi Margin, New Zealand. The bank is located in about 1000 m water depth within the gas hydrate stability field. The seep sites are characterized by active venting and typical methane seep fauna accompanied with patchy carbonate outcrops at the seafloor. Below the seeps, gas migration pathways reach from below the bottom-simulating reflector (at around 380 m sediment depth) toward the seafloor, indicating free gas transport into the shallow hydrate stability field. The CSEM data have been acquired with a seafloor-towed, electric multi-dipole system measuring the inline component of the electric field. CSEM data from three profiles have been analyzed by using 1-D and 2-D inversion techniques. High-resolution 2-D and 3-D multichannel seismic data have been collected in the same area. The electrical resistivity models show several zones of highly anomalous resistivities (〉50 Ωm) which correlate with high amplitude reflections located on top of narrow vertical gas conduits, indicating the coexistence of free gas and gas hydrates within the hydrate stability zone. Away from the seeps the CSEM models show normal background resistivities between ~1 and 2 Ωm. Archie's law has been applied to estimate gas/gas hydrate saturations below the seeps. At intermediate depths between 50 and 200 m below seafloor, saturations are between 40 and 80% and gas hydrate may be the dominating pore filling constituent. At shallow depths from 10 m to the seafloor, free gas dominates as seismic data and gas plumes suggest.