Description: Highlights • Global primitive arc lavas (Mg# ≥60) display notable δ49/47Ti heterogeneity. • Residual rutile imposes high δ49/47Ti of 0.24 ± 0.06 ‰ on hydrous, silicic slab melts. • Primitive Aleutian rhyodacites have the same δ49/47Ti as predicted for slab melts. • A variably diluted signature of slab melts is found in all eight subduction zones. • A slab melt component is required to generate silicic primitive arc lavas. Abstract It is still a matter of intense debate to what extent partial melting of the subducting slab contributes to arc magmatism in modern subduction zones. In particular, it is difficult to differentiate between silicate melts formed by partial melting of the slab, and aqueous fluids released during subsolidus dehydration as the main medium for slab-to-mantle wedge mass transfer. Here we use δ49/47Ti (the deviation in 49Ti/47Ti of a sample to the OL-Ti reference material) as a robust geochemical tracer of slab melting. Hydrous partial melting of subducted oceanic crust and the superjacent sedimentary layer produces silicic melts in equilibrium with residual rutile. Modelling shows that such silicic slab melts have notably higher δ49/47Ti (+0.24 ± 0.06 ‰) than their protolith due to the strong preference of rutile for the lighter isotopes of Ti. In contrast, even highly saline fluids cannot carry Ti from the slab and hence hydrous peridotite partial melts have δ49/47Ti similar to mid-ocean ridge basalts (MORB; ca. 0 ‰). Primitive (Mg# ≥60) arc lavas from eight subduction zones that are unaffected by fractional crystallisation of Fe-Ti oxides show a more than tenfold larger variation in δ49/47Ti than found in MORB. In particular, primitive arc lavas display a striking correlation between SiO2 content and δ49/47Ti that ranges from island arc basalts overlapping with MORB, to primitive rhyodacites with δ49/47Ti up to 0.26 ‰ erupted in the western Aleutian arc. The elevated δ49/47Ti of these primitive arc lavas provides conclusive evidence for partial melts of the slab as a key medium for mass transfer in subduction zones. The Aleutian rhyodacites represent a rare example of slab melts that have traversed the mantle wedge with minimal modification. More commonly, slab melts interact with the mantle wedge to form an array of primary arc magmas that are a blend of slab- and peridotite-derived melt. We identify primitive arc lavas with a clearly resolvable slab melt signature in all eight subduction zone localities, confirming that slab melting is prevalent in modern subduction zones.

Description: To investigate formation of the Earth's earliest continental crust, partial-melting experiments were conducted (at 900–1100 °C and 0.5–3.0 GPa) on two greenstones from the 4.3 Ga Nuvvuagittuq complex of Quebec, Canada. For comparison, experiments were also conducted on a compositionally similar but modern arc volcanic (a Tongan boninite). At 1.5–3.0 GPa and 950–1100 °C, the experimentally produced melts are compositionally similar to the tonalite-trondhjemite-granodiorite (TTG) granitoids that compose most of Earth's early continental crust, including a 3.66 Ga tonalite that encloses the Nuvvuagittuq Complex. Because the degree of melting needed to produce the TTG-like melts is comparatively high (〉30%), the relative concentrations of most incompatible elements in the melts are similar to those in their greenstone parent rocks. These greenstones have compositional affinities with modern subduction zone magmas and do not resemble mid-oceanic ridge basalts. That arc-like mafic rocks could have been selectively involved in TTG formation (in spite of their volumetrically subordinate status in most greenstone terrains) must reflect tectonic circumstances that were specific to their generation. These must have enabled accumulations sufficiently deep to melt at the 1.5–3.0 GPa needed to generate TTG magmas from eclogitic sources. They are also likely to have been related to some form of crustal recycling whereby mafic crust and water were returned to the mantle and arc-like mafic magmas generated as a consequence. To what degree these circumstances replicated modern plate tectonics is difficult to say, but it seems likely that, as in the modern Earth, the Hadean crust was organized into different tectonic environments and that one of these gave rise to the first continental crust.