Description: Harde (2017) proposes an alternative accounting scheme for the modern carbon cycle and concludes that only 4.3% of today's atmospheric CO2 is a result of anthropogenic emissions. As we will show, this alternative scheme is too simple, is based on invalid assumptions, and does not address many of the key processes involved in the global carbon cycle that are important on the timescale of interest. Harde (2017) therefore reaches an incorrect conclusion about the role of anthropogenic CO2 emissions. Harde (2017) tries to explain changes in atmospheric CO2 concentration with a single equation, while the most simple model of the carbon cycle must at minimum contain equations of at least two reservoirs (the atmosphere and the surface ocean), which are solved simultaneously. A single equation is fundamentally at odds with basic theory and observations. In the following we will (i) clarify the difference between CO2 atmospheric residence time and adjustment time, (ii) present recently published information about anthropogenic carbon, (iii) present details about the processes that are missing in Harde (2017), (iv) briefly discuss shortcoming in Harde's generalization to paleo timescales, (v) and comment on deficiencies in some of the literature cited in Harde (2017).

Description: Most dissolved iron in the ocean is bound to organic molecules with strong conditional stability constants, known as ligands that are found at concentrations ranging from 0.2 to more than 10 nmol L− 1. In this work we report the first mechanistic description of ligand dynamics in two three-dimensional models of ocean biogeochemistry and circulation. The model for ligands is based on the concept that ligands are produced both from organic matter remineralization and phytoplankton processes, and that they are lost through bacterial and photochemical degradation, as well as aggregation and to some extent in the process of phytoplankton uptake of ligand-bound iron. A comparison with a compilation of in-situ measurements shows that the model is able to reproduce some large-scale features of the observations, such as a decrease in ligand concentrations along the conveyor belt circulation in the deep ocean, lower surface and subsurface values in the Southern Ocean, or higher values in the mesopelagic than in the abyssal ocean. Modeling ligands prognostically (as opposed to assuming a uniform ligand concentration) leads to a more nutrient-like profile of iron that is more in accordance with data. It however, also leads to higher surface concentrations of dissolved iron and negative excess ligand L⁎ in some ocean regions. This is probably an indication that with more realistic and higher ligand concentrations near the surface, as opposed to the traditionally chosen low uniform concentration, iron modelers will have to re-evaluate their assumption of low scavenging rates for iron. Given their sensitivity to environmental conditions, spatio-temporal variations in ligand concentrations have the potential to impact primary production via changes in iron limitation.

Description: Ikaite (CaCO3·6H2O) has only recently been discovered in sea ice, in a study that also provided first direct evidence of CaCO3 precipitation in sea ice. However, little is as yet known about the impact of physico-chemical processes on ikaite precipitation in sea ice. Our study focused on how the changes in pH, salinity, temperature and phosphate (PO4) concentration affect the precipitation of ikaite. Experiments were set up at pH from 8.5 to 10.0, salinities from 0 to 105 (in both artificial seawater (ASW) and NaCl medium), temperatures from 0 to −4 °C andPO4 concentrations from0 to 50 μmol kg−1. The results show that in ASW, calcium carbonate was precipitated as ikaite under all conditions. In the NaCl medium, the precipitates were ikaite in the presence of PO4 and vaterite in the absence of PO4. The onset time (τ) at which ikaite precipitation started, decreased nonlinearly with increasing pH. In ASW, τ increased with salinity. In the NaCl medium, τ first increased with salinity up to salinity 70 and subsequently decreased with a further increase in salinity; it was longer in ASW than in the NaCl medium under the same salinity. τ did not vary with temperature or PO4 concentration. These results indicate that ikaite is very probably the only phase of calcium carbonate formed in sea ice. PO4 is not, as previously postulated, crucial for ikaite formation in sea ice. The change in pH and salinity is the controlling factor for ikaite precipitation in sea ice. Within the ranges investigated in this study, temperature and PO4 concentration do not have a significant impact on ikaite precipitation.